Domestic Assault & Battery

Domestic assault and battery in Massachusetts is governed by M.G.L. Chapter 265, Section 13M. This statute created a separate criminal offense specifically for assault and battery committed against family or household members, with enhanced penalties beyond regular assault and battery charges.

To convict someone of domestic assault and battery under Section 13M, the prosecution must prove four elements beyond a reasonable doubt.

1. The defendant and alleged victim were family or household members at the time of the incident
2. The defendant touched the alleged victim without legal justification or excuse
3. The touching was intentional (not accidental)
4. The touching was either likely to cause bodily harm OR was done without the victim’s consent

‍Who Qualifies as a Family or Household Member?
‍Massachusetts law defines “family or household member” under Section 13M more narrowly than many people expect. The relationship must fall into one of these categories:People who are or were married to each otherPeople residing together or who resided together in the same householdPeople related by blood or marriagePeople who have a child in common (regardless of whether they ever married or lived together)People who are or have been in a substantive dating or engagement relationshipThis definition differs from the broader definition used for restraining orders under Chapter 209A, which can create confusion about whether charges qualify as “domestic” offenses.

‍What the Prosecution Must Prove
‍The prosecution does not need to prove intent to injure - only that the touching was intentional. Even minor physical contact can support a conviction if it was unwanted and unjustified. Massachusetts courts have established that any intentional touching without consent can constitute assault and battery, even if it causes no visible injury.The “family or household member” relationship element is what distinguishes these charges from regular assault and battery. Once that relationship is established, the case enters a different legal framework with mandatory procedures and enhanced penalties.

‍How the 2014 Law Changed Domestic Violence Prosecution
‍Before 2014, incidents between family members were prosecuted under the general assault and battery statute (M.G.L. Chapter 265, Section 13A). The creation of Section 13M represented Massachusetts’ effort to address domestic violence more seriously through:

- Separate, specific statute for domestic incidents
- Enhanced penalties for subsequent offenses
- Mandatory batterer’s intervention program requirements
- Stricter bail and release procedures
- Six-hour mandatory hold after arrest

These changes reflect the legal system’s recognition that domestic violence cases require different handling than other assault charges.

First Offense Penalties
‍A first offense under M.G.L. Chapter 265, Section 13M is classified as a misdemeanor, punishable by:Up to 2½ years in the house of correctionFine up to $5,000Both imprisonment and fineAdditionally, the law requires completion of a certified batterer’s intervention program unless the judge makes specific written findings that it should not be ordered, or unless the program determines the defendant is unsuitable for intervention.

‍Batterer’s Intervention Program Requirements: - Weekly group sessions totaling minimum 80 hours - Additional 4-6 week introduction period at program start - Ongoing program contact with alleged victims - Program fees and time commitment over several months - Court monitoring of complianceCourts rarely waive this requirement. The statute mandates judicial findings to explain any decision not to order program completion.

‍Second or Subsequent Offense - Felony ClassificationA second or subsequent domestic assault and battery conviction becomes a felony under Massachusetts law, carrying significantly enhanced penalties:Up to 2½ years in the house of correction, ORUp to 5 years in state prisonThe escalation from misdemeanor to felony status for repeat offenses creates substantial long-term consequences beyond the immediate penalties.

‍Collateral ConsequencesRestraining Orders: Domestic assault and battery charges typically result in restraining orders prohibiting contact with the alleged victim. This can mean immediate removal from your home, separation from children, and restrictions on familiar locations.

‍Employment Impact: Domestic violence convictions appear on standard background checks and may disqualify candidates from positions in education, healthcare, government, and roles involving vulnerable populations.

‍Professional Licensing: Medical, legal, nursing, teaching, and other professional licenses may require reporting of domestic violence convictions, potentially triggering disciplinary proceedings or license suspension.

‍Firearm Prohibition: Federal law permanently prohibits anyone convicted of a misdemeanor crime of domestic violence from possessing firearms or ammunition. This lifetime ban applies to first offenses and cannot be removed through expungement or sealing.

Every domestic assault and battery case involves unique facts requiring individualized defense strategies. However, several common defense approaches apply across many cases.

‍Self-Defense
‍Massachusetts law recognizes the right to use reasonable force to protect oneself from harm. Self-defense requires showing:The defendant reasonably believed they faced imminent harmThe force used was proportional to the threatThe defendant had no reasonable means of avoiding the confrontationThe defense applies when someone acts to protect themselves from actual or reasonably perceived danger from the alleged victim.

‍Defense of Others
‍Similar to self-defense, Massachusetts law permits reasonable force to protect third parties from harm. This applies when the defendant reasonably believed another person faced imminent danger requiring protective action.
‍
‍Accident
‍If contact was accidental rather than intentional, it doesn’t satisfy the legal elements of assault and battery. The prosecution must prove intentional touching - mere negligence or accident is insufficient for conviction.

‍Lack of Evidence
‍Challenging whether sufficient evidence exists to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. This includes questioning:Whether contact actually occurred as allegedWhether the contact was intentionalWhether the alleged victim consented to the contactWhether the prosecution can prove the incident occurred at all

‍Challenging the Relationship Element
‍If the prosecution cannot prove the defendant and alleged victim qualify as “family or household members” under Section 13M’s definition, the domestic charge may not apply (though regular assault and battery charges might still proceed).

‍Credibility Issues
Many domestic cases involve conflicting accounts without independent witnesses. Defense may focus on:Motive to fabricate (custody disputes, divorce, immigration concerns, revenge)Inconsistencies in alleged victim’s statementsPrior false allegationsEvidence contradicting the alleged victim’s accountPhysical evidence inconsistent with allegations

‍Mutual Combat
‍In situations where both parties were physical aggressors, challenging which party was the primary aggressor and whether police arrested the wrong person.

Every case is different. What works depends entirely on your specific facts, your evidence, and your circumstances. Early investigation, preservation of evidence, and experienced legal representation make the difference between favorable outcomes and worst-case scenarios.

Don't face this alone — contact us today for a confidential consultation to discuss your case and explore your defense options.